Article
Click-to-Open Rate vs Click-Through Rate: What Each Metric Really Measures
By Unlimited Verifier Team ·

Summary
Click-through rate (CTR) divides unique clicks by delivered emails, measuring how the whole list responded. Click-to-open rate (CTOR) divides unique clicks by unique opens, measuring how well content performs among people who read the email. For the same send, CTOR is equal to or higher than CTR.Click-to-open rate (CTOR) and click-through rate (CTR) both count unique clicks, but they divide by different things. CTR divides unique clicks by delivered emails, so it measures how many recipients clicked. CTOR divides unique clicks by unique opens, so it measures how many readers clicked. For the same send, CTOR is equal to or higher than CTR. For a wider view of targets, start with our pillar guide on email marketing benchmarks.
Quick answer
- CTR = unique clicks ÷ delivered emails. Use it as your headline number for each send.
- CTOR = unique clicks ÷ unique opens. Use it to diagnose content, layout and calls to action among people who read the email.
- CTOR should never be lower than CTR for the same send. If it is, your clicks and opens came from different reports.
- Open data is distorted. Apple's privacy features inflate opens, and corporate link scanners can inflate clicks, so check both before you act.
- Clean the list before you measure. Catch-all and dead-but-accepted addresses sit in your delivered count and quietly dilute CTR.
What is the difference between click-to-open rate and click-through rate?
The two metrics share a numerator, the number of unique people who clicked at least one link. The denominator is the only difference. CTR counts everyone the server accepted. CTOR counts only the people who opened the email.
| Metric | Formula | Denominator | What it tells you | Main weakness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Click-through rate (CTR) | Unique clicks ÷ delivered | Everyone the receiving server accepted | How the whole list responded to the send | Diluted by addresses that accept mail but never get read |
| Click-to-open rate (CTOR) | Unique clicks ÷ unique opens | People who opened the email | Content and call-to-action quality among readers | Distorted when opens are inflated or under-counted |
| Open rate (reference) | Unique opens ÷ delivered | Everyone the receiving server accepted | Whether the subject line and sender earned a look | Unreliable since Apple's 2021 privacy changes |
Here "delivered" means accepted by the receiving server. The SMTP standard defines a 250 reply as "requested mail action okay, completed" (RFC 5321). It does not mean the message reached the inbox. Some platforms define delivered differently, so check your ESP's definition before comparing numbers across tools.
Bottom line: Same clicks, different denominators. Choose the denominator that matches the question you are asking.
How do you calculate CTR and CTOR correctly?
Calculate both metrics from unique counts and delivered volume, pulled from the same report. Most reporting errors come from using total clicks, sent volume, or a mix of sources.
- Unique clicks count each person once. Total clicks count every click, so one person who clicks three links inflates the rate three times.
- Delivered equals sent minus bounces. Using sent volume understates CTR, because bounced addresses never had a chance to click.
- Unique opens count each person once. Total opens can be several times higher than unique opens for the same audience, because people reopen emails.
Worked arithmetic: A send produced 588 unique clicks, 2,940 unique opens and 19,600 delivered emails.
- CTR = 588 ÷ 19,600 = 3.0%
- CTOR = 588 ÷ 2,940 = 20.0%
Both figures are correct, and they answer different questions. The 3.0% describes the whole list. The 20.0% describes the readers.
Bottom line: Use unique counts over delivered (for CTR) or opens (for CTOR). Anything else mixes populations.
Which metric should you trust more?
Trust CTR more as your headline number, because it depends only on click and delivery data. CTOR is best used as a diagnostic, and only with an understanding of its open-data problem.
Since Apple introduced Mail Privacy Protection in 2021, Apple's servers pre-fetch images for many Apple Mail users, which can register an open even when nobody reads the email. Our guide to why open rates are unreliable after Apple Mail Privacy Protection explains the mechanics. Those pre-fetches inflate the CTOR denominator, which pushes the rate down even when real engagement is unchanged.
Here is the practical nuance most summaries skip. CTOR is still useful for A/B tests of the same send. Pre-fetch inflation hits both variants, so the comparison holds up as long as the two groups have similar Apple Mail shares. That share varies by audience, so check it before you split a segment that is heavy on iPhone users.
| Pattern | CTR | CTOR | What it most likely means |
|---|---|---|---|
| CTR steady, CTOR falls | Stable | Down | Open inflation, not reader fatigue |
| CTR falls, CTOR steady | Down | Stable | Fewer people reached, through bounces or spam placement |
| Both fall | Down | Down | Real drop in engagement: check the offer, timing or segment |
| CTR rises, CTOR flat | Up | Stable | More of the list is engaging, often after a cleanup or segment change |
Bottom line: Judge a campaign on CTR. Use CTOR to explain what happened inside it, and compare variants only when their audiences match.
Why does click-to-open rate move when the tracking is wrong?
CTOR can break in two directions, and you need to know which one is happening before you act on a change.
- Inflated opens push CTOR down. Pre-fetches and security scans register opens that never involved a person reading. A bigger denominator makes the same clicks look like a smaller share.
- Inflated clicks push both metrics up. Corporate security gateways sometimes follow links automatically to check them. Those requests can register as clicks.
Bot clicks are the more dangerous distortion, because they make a weak campaign look strong. Treat a sudden CTR jump with no change in content as something to investigate, not a win to celebrate. Two signals help: clicks that arrive within seconds of sending, and clicks that cluster on one link or one email domain.
The table below uses hypothetical numbers from the same send to show both effects. Assume 1,470 of the 2,940 reported opens were pre-fetches, and 196 of the 588 clicks came from link scanners.
| Version | Unique clicks | Unique opens | Delivered | CTR | CTOR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| As reported (includes pre-fetch opens) | 588 | 2,940 | 19,600 | 3.0% | 20.0% |
| Pre-fetch opens removed (1,470 real opens) | 588 | 1,470 | 19,600 | 3.0% | 40.0% |
| Scanner clicks removed (from reported) | 392 | 2,940 | 19,600 | 2.0% | 13.3% |
The middle row changes CTOR without any change in reader behaviour. The bottom row lowers both metrics, which is the correct outcome, because the campaign was weaker than it looked.
Bottom line: Neither metric is clean by default. Identify which distortion is present before drawing a conclusion.
Does email verification improve click-through rate?
Verification improves CTR indirectly, and the effect on the headline number is often smaller than senders expect. Its bigger payoff is in bounce rate and inbox placement over time.
Here is the part that matters for CTR. Hard bounces are removed from the delivered count automatically, so they don't affect CTR once they're excluded. The problem is addresses that don't bounce but never get read. A catch-all domain accepts any address at the SMTP stage, so a dead mailbox on that domain counts as delivered and drags CTR down silently. That is why the verification step matters even when bounces look healthy. Verification's catch-all flag identifies these addresses, which bounce-based cleaning cannot see.
Worked example: A list of 20,000 contacts produced 400 bounces (2.0%), leaving 19,600 delivered. The send generated 588 unique clicks.
- CTR on sent volume = 588 ÷ 20,000 = 2.94%
- CTR on delivered volume = 588 ÷ 19,600 = 3.0%
After verification, the sections below show what changes. Verification also flags role-based addresses such as info@, which rarely click and often go to shared inboxes, and disposable addresses, which rarely engage. Both drag engagement numbers down while looking like real contacts.
Verification is part of email verification compliance and hygiene. It protects deliverability first, and an honest CTR is a side effect.
Bottom line: Bounce removal fixes the bounce rate. Catch-all and role-based flags fix the CTR, which bounce data can't show.
What are good click-to-open and click-through rates?
No single published figure answers this, and sources disagree. Benchmark reports sample different industries, list sizes and tracking methods, so their averages are not directly comparable. Treat any published average as a rough direction, not a target.
Our recommendation: compare each send against your own trailing 90-day median first. Then add one published source for your industry as context. Don't average several reports together, because the averages aren't measuring the same thing.
To choose that source, start with average email click-through rate by industry and the email marketing benchmarks by industry 2026 roundup. Senders in specific categories often need a narrower comparison. Ecommerce teams should check ecommerce email marketing benchmarks, and nonprofits should look at nonprofit email marketing benchmarks. Ecommerce and SaaS lists also churn quickly, so the verification context in email verification for ecommerce and SaaS applies to how you read your baseline.
Clicks mean little if complaints are rising. Google's bulk sender guidance says to keep user-reported spam below 0.10% and to avoid reaching 0.30%. Our guide to what is a good spam complaint rate explains why we recommend a tighter internal ceiling than Google's threshold.
Bottom line: Benchmark against your own 90-day median, and treat complaints as the metric that can override any click result.
How do you measure both metrics step by step?
Follow this five-step framework for every campaign. It takes about ten minutes once your spreadsheet is set up.
- Fix the denominators. Record delivered (sent minus bounces) and use it for CTR. Never use sent volume for CTR.
- Use unique counts from one report. Pull unique clicks and unique opens from the same export and the same date range.
- Screen for machine activity. Check whether click spikes arrive within minutes of sending, cluster on one domain, or appear without matching site traffic. Those patterns suggest scanners.
- Report CTR as the headline and CTOR as the diagnostic. Compare sends on CTR. Compare subject lines, layouts and calls to action on CTOR, and only within audiences with similar Apple Mail shares.
- Compare to your baseline and check complaints. Flag any send that falls more than a few points from your rolling 90-day median, and check complaint rate before you call it a win. Google Postmaster Tools shows spam-rate data for Gmail traffic, when you send enough volume to display it (Google Postmaster Tools). Our guide to deliverability metrics every sender should track lists the companion metrics.
Bottom line: Consistent denominators and a personal baseline matter more than any industry average.
How do you calculate CTR and CTOR in a spreadsheet?
This tutorial works with any ESP that exports campaign reports as CSV or Excel. Column names vary, so match them to your export's labels.
- Export the campaign report. Copy sent, bounces, unique opens and unique clicks for one campaign.
- Set up columns. Put them in one row, in this order: A Campaign, B Sent, C Bounces, D Delivered, E Unique opens, F Unique clicks, G CTR, H CTOR, I Check.
- Calculate delivered. In D2, enter
=B2-C2. - Calculate CTR. In G2, enter
=F2/D2. Format the cell as a percentage with one decimal place. - Calculate CTOR. In H2, enter
=F2/E2, formatted the same way. - Run the sanity check. In I2, enter
=IF(H2>=G2,"OK","Recheck data"). If you see "Recheck data", re-pull the report before drawing conclusions. - Export the list you plan to mail next. Export it as a CSV. If you are on the Free plan, note that each list is capped at 150 emails and you get 25 lists a month, so larger files need splitting or the Pro plan.
- Upload and verify. Go to upload and verify a list. CSV and Excel files up to 10MB are accepted, and the email column is detected automatically. Pro lists can hold up to 25,000 emails each.
- Read the three buckets. Valid addresses are safe for your next send. Invalid addresses should be suppressed. Risky addresses include catch-all domains, which accept any address, so the mailbox can't be confirmed. Hold Risky addresses back from early sends.
- Download results immediately. Export as CSV, Excel or JSON. Free plan results are kept for 24 hours, while Pro plan results are kept for 30 days, so save a copy either way.
- Re-import Valid contacts and suppress Invalid ones. Unlimited Verifier doesn't have native ESP, CRM or Zapier integrations, so the workflow is export, verify, re-import. If you need automation, see email verification API and automation.
To spot-check a single address, such as a high-value contact that came back Risky, use the free email checker.
Bottom line: Compute the two metrics correctly, then clean the list so the next send's denominator reflects real, reachable people.
What does a 20,000-contact cleanup do to your numbers?
This example uses hypothetical results with real plan limits.
Starting point: 20,000 contacts sent, 400 hard bounces, 19,600 delivered, 2,940 unique opens, 588 unique clicks.
- CTR = 588 ÷ 19,600 = 3.0%
- CTOR = 588 ÷ 2,940 = 20.0%
- Bounce rate = 400 ÷ 20,000 = 2.0%
Diagnosis: CTR looks healthy, but the 2.0% bounce rate is a warning sign. Our guide to how to calculate email bounce rate covers the formula, and email list maintenance best practices covers the schedule that prevents this.
Plan fit: On the Free plan, a 20,000-email list would need 134 lists (20,000 ÷ 150 = 133.3, rounded up), and Free allows only 25 lists a month, so it won't fit. Pro costs $29 a month, or $25 a month billed annually ($300 a year). It handles the full list in one file, since lists can hold up to 25,000 emails. Its 25,000 monthly deep verifications cover all 20,000 contacts with 5,000 to spare, and standard verification is unlimited on every plan. For a broader cost comparison, see email verification pricing.
Cleaning: Suppose the verification output is 18,900 Valid, 700 Risky and 400 Invalid. The 400 Invalid addresses match the bounces you already saw, which suggests the process caught the known problems. The 700 Risky contacts stay out of the first sends.
Re-send to Valid only: Assume the Risky group produced 21 of the earlier clicks and 105 of the earlier opens, which is 3.0% CTR and 20.0% CTOR on that group. Removing them gives:
- Clicks: 588 − 21 = 567
- Opens: 2,940 − 105 = 2,835
- CTR = 567 ÷ 18,900 = 3.0%
- CTOR = 567 ÷ 2,835 = 20.0%
The CTR is unchanged, but the reputation gain is real. Your next bounce rate is controlled, so you can judge engagement on a base you trust. The Risky group's clicks were not wasted, because they showed you that the group engages at the same rate as the rest of the list. That is a finding worth keeping for a later test.
Bottom line: Cleanup often leaves CTR unchanged. What it removes is the bounce risk and the unreadable addresses that would have eroded your numbers over time.
What mistakes distort click-to-open and click-through rates?
- Using sent volume as the CTR denominator. This counts addresses that bounced and never had a chance to click, so the rate looks worse than the list really is.
- Using total clicks instead of unique clicks. Repeat clickers inflate the rate and hide how many people actually engaged.
- Mixing data sources. Taking clicks from one export and opens from another can produce a CTOR that is lower than CTR, which is impossible if the data is consistent.
- Blaming content for a CTOR drop. Check first whether Apple Mail's pre-fetches grew in your audience.
- Celebrating a click spike that arrives minutes after sending. Scanner activity looks like a win in the report.
- Comparing against a single industry average. A published figure may reflect a different sender size, list age or tracking method.
- Ignoring complaints because clicks look strong. Complaints can turn a strong send into an account-level problem.
- Measuring before you clean. Catch-all and dead addresses dilute the next send's results, so verify first, then measure. For prevention at the point of collection, see real-time email validation.
Bottom line: Most distorted metrics come from the denominator, the counting method or an unexamined spike.
How we compared (and limitations)
This article is based on public documentation and widely reported sender requirements: Google's bulk sender guidance, Google Postmaster Tools, the SMTP specification in RFC 5321, and the FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide. We have not run controlled tests of any ESP's reporting. Metric definitions vary by platform, so check your own dashboard before comparing numbers across tools.
Benchmark ranges are directional, and sources disagree on exact values. The worked examples use hypothetical figures.
Unlimited Verifier's stated accuracy for deep verification is 99.5%. That is the company's own figure, not an independent benchmark. Plan details are as published by Unlimited Verifier. To see how verification fits your own data, create a free account and run your first list.
Worked CTR and CTOR calculation
A send produced 588 unique clicks, 2,940 unique opens and 19,600 delivered emails.
| Metric | Formula | Result |
|---|---|---|
| CTR | 588 ÷ 19,600 | 3.0% |
| CTOR | 588 ÷ 2,940 | 20.0% |
Both are correct. CTR tells you the list responded at 3.0%. CTOR tells you that 1 in 5 readers clicked.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good click-to-open rate?
There is no universal benchmark, because CTOR depends on industry, list type and content. Most teams compare their own sends over time rather than against a fixed number. Use your own trailing average as the baseline and judge changes against it.
Can click-to-open rate be higher than 100%?
No. Unique clicks cannot exceed unique opens if every click comes from a recipient who opened the email. If you see a value above 100%, check whether clicks are counted from a different source or from non-unique totals.
Why is CTOR usually higher than CTR?
CTOR uses a smaller denominator, unique opens, which excludes recipients who never opened the email. Because clicks almost always come from openers, dividing by a smaller base produces a higher percentage for the same clicks.
Is CTR or CTOR more important?
CTR is usually the headline metric for each send because it reflects the whole audience. CTOR is better for diagnosing content and calls to action among readers. Use both together rather than picking one.
Why are open rates unreliable?
Apple Mail Privacy Protection, introduced in 2021, preloads tracking pixels, which inflates opens for affected recipients. Because CTOR uses opens as its denominator, the same distortion affects it, so treat both with caution.
Should I use unique or total clicks?
Use unique clicks for both CTR and CTOR. Total clicks count repeat clicks by the same person, which inflates the rate and makes results hard to compare across lists of different sizes.
What causes a CTOR lower than CTR?
This usually means the clicks and opens came from different reports, date ranges or segments. Pull both numbers from the same send and time window. A genuine CTOR below CTR is mathematically impossible for one send.
Do security scanners affect click rates?
Yes. Corporate email security tools often follow links automatically, which can register clicks nobody made. Filter out known scanner activity where your platform allows it, and review click spikes that arrive seconds after delivery.
Cut Bounces and Protect Your Sender Reputation With Unlimited Email Verification
Every invalid address you send to hurts your sender reputation and your inbox placement. Verifying your list before each send means fewer bounces, healthier deliverability, and a predictable cost. With Unlimited Verifier, standard verification is unlimited on every plan, with no per-email fees.
Unlimited Verifier checks syntax, domain, MX records and the SMTP mailbox. It also detects catch-all domains and flags disposable and role-based addresses. Export a CSV from your email platform or CRM, upload and verify the list, then re-import the clean results. You can also automate checks with the email verification API.
| Free | Pro | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $0 | $29/month ($25/month billed annually) |
| Lists | 25 a month, up to 150 emails each | Unlimited, up to 25,000 emails each |
| Deep verifications | 750 a month | 25,000 a month |
| API access | No | Yes (100,000 emails a month) |
| Result retention | 24 hours | 30 days |
Why teams choose Unlimited Verifier
- Unlimited standard verification on all plans, including Free, with no per-email fees.
- Catch-all detection so you know which domains accept every address.
- Clear Valid / Risky / Invalid results, exportable as CSV, Excel or JSON.
- An open-source verification engine you can inspect on GitHub.
Unlimited Verifier states 99.5% accuracy for deep verification.
Create a free account and verify your next list before you hit send.
Want to test a single address first? Try the free email checker.